🥥 The Best Homemade Coconut Cream Pie Recipe with Custard Filling (2024)

The best homemade Coconut Cream Pie recipe, featuring a creamy custard base, fluffy whipped cream topping, and toasted coconut flakes. Perfect for coconut lovers, this easy-to-follow recipe guarantees a delicious dessert!

This Old Fashioned Coconut Cream Pie recipe is the timeless dessert, perfectly blending a homemade custard base with the rich flavors of coconut cream. Whether you’re using a traditional baked crust or a crumbly graham cracker base, this pie promises to be a hit.

Learn how to create a smooth filling, homemade whipped cream and toasted coconut. It’s homestyle cooking at its best.

What is a cream pie?

There are different cream pie recipes. Some start with ingredients as simple as instant pudding. These pudding cream pies are no-bake and no cook. They are quick and easy.

But the best cream pie is one that starts with a homemade custard filling that you cook on the stovetop. This thickens up, tastes like a homemade pudding and is the base to the cream pie.

Ingredients

• Pie shell. Use a homemade pie crust or graham cracker crust. Just make sure the pie crust is baked since this is a no bake pie filling.
• Milk and cream. 2% milk will work, but I prefer whole milk along with the heavy cream which will make a creamy coconut filling.
• Cornstarch and flour. These both work together to thicken the custard base.
• Egg yolks. You’ll only use egg yolks, so save the whites for roasted pecans, meringue or an omelette.

Preparing the Pie Crust

A homemade crust gives your pie a personal touch. Make my grandma’s pie crust recipe (the base of all of my favorite pies), oatmeal pie crust or a graham cracker crust.

Whichever you choose, make sure the crust is baked in advance. Bake until the crust is golden brown, usually around 15-20 minutes, for that perfect flaky pie crust.

Make the Creamy Coconut Custard

• Using a heavy bottomed medium saucepan over set to medium heat, warm 1 ¾ cup milk. Heat for 3-4 minutes, stirring often, just until the milk starts to get warm.
• While the milk is heating, mix together the sugar, salt, cornstarch, and flour in a small bowl. Add the remaining ½ cup of milk and whisk until smooth. Drizzle the milk/sugar mixture into the hot milk, whisking constantly as you drizzle it in. Cook, stirring constantly until it starts to simmer slightly and thicken, then reduce heat to low heat, cover the pan and cook for an additional 5 minutes, stirring often.
• Place the egg yolks in a small bowl and whisk them to break up the yolks. Remove ¼ cup of the hot cream mixture and add it to the eggs, whisking constantly. This is called tempering the eggs. Drizzle the egg mixture into the hot cream, whisking constantly. Cook for an additional 2 minutes or until thickened, again, whisking constantly. It should be the consistency of pudding when it is ready.
• Remove the pan from the heat. Add in the butter, coconut flavor and shredded coconut. Stir well with a rubber spatula.

Allow the custard to cool for 10 minutes, then fill the pie shell.

Homemade Whipped Cream

To make whipped cream, begin with cold heavy cream, coconut flavor and powdered sugar. Whip until stiff peaks form.

You can substitute homemade whipped cream with Cool Whip whipped topping for convenience if you prefer.

Finishing Touches

This pie looks gorgeous with toasted coconut on top.

Spread shredded coconut on a baking sheet. Toast the coconut at 325ºF for 7-8 minutes or until golden brown.

This not only enhances the flavor but also adds a lovely texture and color contrast to the top of the pie.

Other Cream Pie Recipes

• Homemade Custard Pie
• Amish Pineapple Pie
• Banana Cream Pie
• Maple Nut Pie
• Cream Cheese Lime Pie